A T Still University Public Health Commerce Clause Essay

Toobin and Breyer present two different perspectives on the importance of justices being politicians. In 3-5 pages, indicate your position on how important it is for justices to be politicians and indicate if you feel the court system is pluralist or elitist as defined by your textbook.

Use the weakening of the Commerce Clause in United State v Lopez and the June 2012 Affordable Care Act ruling by the Roberts Court as a case study to support your positions. Your position should also include the implications of a weaker Commerce Clause on determinants of health.